EMA Recording & Book Reviews

Reviews by the editorial staff of Early Music America. Have a new recording or book? Submit it for consideration.


The Butter Quartet, Spreading Love of the Galant

The Butter Quartet, Spreading Love of the Galant

Ken Meltzer
The Butter Quartet, who met as students at the Royal Conservatory of the Hague, released their debut recording with 'Scintilla: Early Italian String Quartets.' In buoyant, impeccable playing, they capture the galant spirit of music by Pugnani, Boccherini, Lombardini Sirmen, and Giardini. Excellent performances of attractive, varied repertoire.
Courtly and Colonial Music in Mughal India

Courtly and Colonial Music in Mughal India

Aruna Kharod
With a lively writing style, Katherine Butler Schofield's 'Music and Musicians in Late Mughal India: Histories of the Ephemeral, 1748-1858' offers a deeply researched study of early Hindustani musical practices in courtly and colonial settings. The era is one of sociopolitical transition during the century of the powerful British East India Company’s conquest of India.
The Obsessive Violinist

The Obsessive Violinist

Aaron Keebaugh
Canadian violinist Marie Nadeau-Tremblay plays with uncommon immediacy, spontaneity, and rhetorical ease. In her latest recording, the violinist and her outstanding partners obsess over music by Biber, Buxtehude, Guillemain, and Francoeur -- all delivered in three full dimensions and with real Baroque fire.
Campra and the Choral Masters of Notre-Dame

Campra and the Choral Masters of Notre-Dame

Jeffrey Baxter
With Notre-Dame set to reopen in December, this fine new recording celebrates sacred music linked to the cathedral, anchored by André Campra’s beloved Requiem. But the most interesting listening may be the handful of rarely heard motets, hymns, and mass settings by earlier composers at Notre-Dame.
Sensational Haydn from Rachel Podger and Tafelmusik

Sensational Haydn from Rachel Podger and Tafelmusik

Ken Meltzer
Toronto's Tafelmusik, led by British violinist Rachel Podger, wholeheartedly embrace the 'Sturm und Drang' of Haydn's middle period symphonies. Their razor-sharp ensemble and deep musicality make these live recordings thoroughly satisfying.
A Monumental New Study of the Horn

A Monumental New Study of the Horn

Richard Seraphinoff
It's been decades since a comprehensive history of the horn has been published in English, suitable for both the scholar and the performer. The Horn, by Renato Meucci and Gabriele Rocchetti, rises to the challenge. The authors unearth much new information and paint a clear picture of the instrument's rich history.
Jewish Heroism, Italian Oratorio

Jewish Heroism, Italian Oratorio

Ian Pomerantz
A new, complete recording of Alessandro Stradella's 1673 biblical oratorio 'Ester' looks deeper than its Italian Counter-Reformation inspiration and goes back to the story's Jewish roots, centered on themes of resistance and survival owing to one woman's courage. Camerata Grimani and its strong Italian and American cast perform with rhetorical flair and, refreshingly, a Mediterranean sense of expression.
Going Solo with Viadana

Going Solo with Viadana

Anne E. Johnson
Italian composer and Franciscan friar Lodovico Viadana, born c. 1560 near Mantua, was a pioneer in the new expressive monody in church music. The Viadana Collective makes its stunning recording debut with music from their namesake's 'Centum sacri concentus ab una voce sola,' codifying the sound of solo voices with instrumental accompaniment.
Exuberant Bach from Mahan Esfahani

Exuberant Bach from Mahan Esfahani

Steven Silverman
Mahan Esfahani's J.S. Bach recordings, on harpsichord and clavichord, are rich in virtuosity and imagination. Although the music on this newest album, including preludes, inventions, and sinfonias, was composed for teaching purposes, Esfahani sees beyond the printed page and manages to coax a vocal character from his instrument.
On Materiality of Musical Sources

On Materiality of Musical Sources

Anya B. Wilkening
Using the in-vogue terms of 'media' and 'materiality,' this collection finds insights in the objects of everyday music-making. Its chapters cover a range of topics, from conventional notation to the layout and decorations of illuminated manuscripts. In case after case, the visual, textual, and tactile effects of a manuscript impacted how the musicians engaged with its content.
Scroll to Top